libera/#devuan/ Monday, 2023-06-12

tacpilotprolly been asked a million times already .. buuuut I just logged in ... do we have a release date target for Daedalus  ?05:53
golinuxWhen it's ready05:54
tacpilotalways understand that to be true ... is there a wishful thinking pin I can put in my calendar :)05:55
tacpiloteven if the granularity is on a month ?05:56
onefangJust wait for the next million to ask, then it's some time after that.  Or maybe before.05:56
golinuxNo kidding . . .05:57
tacpilotand with millions ..just just shows how much the community hates that Debian climbed in bed with system d06:00
tacpilot198 in this channel alone .. all protesting and chanting bring back systemd .. oh well .. been patiently waiting for bookworm to drop but have no idea the lag time for devuan .. fingers X'd it wont take too long ..06:06
tacpilotwas forced to hodge-podge my current system for compat reasons which has introduced some quirks .. wouldnt otherwise be so on the edge of my seat looking for the next release06:08
golinuxPlease take you soliloquy to devuan-offtopic . . .06:10
golinuxThis is a technical support channel . . . If you have a technical question, please ask.06:11
tacpilottnx devs for their hard work .. tips hat .. shows self to door .. cheers all..06:13
fluffywolfI have heard daedalus is installable and very usable, but I haven't tried it myself yet.06:13
brocashelmbeen using daedalus since february IIRC; switched from ceres06:15
brocashelmhardly any issues i've come across since then. it was just a patience thing for it to stabilize06:15
brocashelmoriginally installed as beowulf, then moved my way up...06:16
brocashelmi suppose all we're waiting for is /etc/os-release to change from daedalus/ceres to daedalus?06:18
brocashelmalready went and did that myself, anyhow...06:19
gnarfacedaedalus is working fine here as well, on a desktop i merged from ceres around the same time as brocashelm, i think, as well as two arm sbc boards (one upgraded from chimaera, one freshly debootstrapped as daedalus)06:20
gnarfacei've had some minor issues with some games in Steam, but they are the types of issues that have come and gone over the past years unrelated to current distro so i don't have any particular reason to think they're daedalus' fault (some of the same issues have persisted since beowulf)06:22
grayrockthe steam games i've tried in daedalus haven't had any more problems than usual. they work pretty well in fact.06:36
brocashelmwhat's perplexing is there are only i386 builds of it to this day06:39
brocashelmwait, i guess it's now a transitional package for steam-installer?06:40
brocashelmit's been a while since i last used steam06:41
grayrocki still just do: dpkg --add-architecture i386 && apt update && apt upgrade && apt install steam06:46
grayrockworks every time.06:46
gnarfaceyea the game catalog is a mix so you usually need both architectures anyway06:48
gnarfacelots of windows programs themselves use both architectures indiscriminately, it's nowhere near as organized as the open source ecosystem06:50
gnarfacemicrosoft has set absolutely no expectation there will be 64-bit versions of everything so you frequently have 64-bit games unabashedly relying on 32-bit apis06:50
grayrockproton works surprisingly well. i just set it to use proton-experimental and forget about it.06:51
gnarfaceso i guess for whatever reason, Steam decided to preserve this misbehavior on linux, maybe to make the windows people feel at home06:51
gnarfaceonce again i've kited us offtopic though, sorry06:51
grayrockheh.06:52
gnarfaceif anyone needs any daedalus-specific fixes for Steam or Valve hardware, i have a few in my head though, so let me know06:52
gnarfacewell, devuan specific really06:52
gnarface(there are a couple things that expect systemd or pulseaudio that take some clever tricks to work around)06:52
gnarfaceat least you usually don't have to go deleting .so files anymore06:54
gnarfaceusually06:54
grayrocki'll report that the radeon rx 6650-xt gpu works with with daedalus. and the asrock b650 pg lightning am5 motherboard.06:55
grayrockquestion: is kvm no longer in the devuan repo?07:02
gnarfaceyou probably mean qemu07:03
grayrockno, qemu is there, but virtinstaller used to install both as dependencies. now it installs qemu and something else.07:04
grayrocki mean virtmanager07:04
brocashelmi installed virtualbox from ceres; it's the only popular vm client that's worked for me07:06
grayrockvirtualbox is ok, but qemu-kvm is just the cat's [redacted]07:09
gnarfacegrayrock: kvm is still there if you use "-enable-kvm" on the command-line. they just removed the package "qemu-kvm" for whatever reason.08:01
gnarfacegrayrock: i don't use virtmanager, i just run it from the command-line.08:01
gnarfaceyou may have to debug virtmanager's command-line options separately08:02
gnarfaceqemu-system-x86 is marked as "Replaces: qemu-kvm" here08:04
gnarfacealso, "Provides: qemu-kvm, qemu-system-i386, qemu-system-x86-64"08:04
gnarfacei'd recommend getting it running from a bare command line then debug virtmanager second08:05
grayrockgnarface: thank you very very much for finding that out. i really appreciate it.08:05
gnarfacenp08:06
grayrockyeh, that seems like the best way to do it now. i'll figure something out.08:06
gnarfaceyou're using a amd64 machine?08:09
grayrockyes.08:10
gnarfaceqemu-system-x86_64 -enable-kvm -cpu host -m 2G -boot c -drive file=~/some_disk_file.img,if=virtio,index=0,media=disk,format=qcow2 -rtc base=localtime,clock=host -object rng-random,id=rngid0,filename=/dev/random -vga virtio -nic none08:11
gnarfacethis is the base i'm working with08:11
gnarfacenot sure it's perfect yet but it's functional08:11
* grayrock copies and pastes08:12
gnarfacethe .img file there has to be created first08:12
gnarfacei made it with qemu-img08:12
gnarface(check the man page)08:12
gnarfacei think you can in theory just feed it any disk image if you change the mount options slightly08:13
grayrockawesome.08:13
gnarfacethe primary feature i liked about qcow2 is just that it can "grow" on the fly08:14
gnarfaceyou can set a max value but keep it from taking up that space until it needs it08:14
gnarfaceit's probably slow though by comparison to a raw image08:17
gnarfaceor a actual disk partition08:17
gnarface(which you could use instead if you wanted)08:18
grayrockit's been a whgile for me so i'll have to relearn it. i really only used virt-manager because it installed all the dependencies i'd have had to do by hand. pure laziness.08:18
grayrockimma turn in. thanks again, that above and beyond.08:19
grayrockyou oughta write that up and post it somewhere, btw.08:20
grayrocknite08:20
hacksenwerkHi. A user in #devuan-arm told me that devuan pushes in packages that are not really necessary sometimes and he gave me one example with the package networkmanager: https://paste.debian.net/plain/1282734 I don't know if that's true and I donÄt care about networkmanager anyway, but I asked him to report thatand he denied, so I do that now.14:18
fsmithredhacksenwerk, try 'apt show network-manager' in debian and in devuan to comare the Depends and the Recommends. What you posted doesn't prove anything because we don't know what packages were already installed on the Debian system they used.14:23
fsmithredcompare14:23
hacksenwerkfsmithred: Yes I said to him something like this.14:24
hacksenwerkAlso, that it also could be that there are additional packages needed on devuan to replace systemd dependencies14:25
hacksenwerkAnd hes not in this channel here, so...14:25
fsmithredor look at this list: https://packages.debian.org/bullseye/network-manager14:26
hacksenwerkfsmithred: I forwarded it to him.14:27
hacksenwerkI also told hm to deny apt installin grecommends14:28
fsmithredyeah,, that can be helpful to reduce bloat14:28
hacksenwerkfsmithred: yup. but allow recommends important14:28
hacksenwerkfsmithred: He said you are wrong.14:29
fsmithredwrong about what?14:29
hacksenwerkOk I stop that game, that's ridicoulus, if he really has to say something he can come here hisself14:29
hacksenwerkfsmithred: he's here -> #devuan-arm14:30
hacksenwerkfsmithred: Ok now I'm sure he's a troll ;)14:31
fsmithredI think your initial assessment was correct - I see a lot of elogind stuff in the devuan output.14:31
fsmithredso yeah, it's replacing stuff from systemd that he already has installed in debian.14:32
fsmithredand maybe second assessment is right, too. i.e. troll. I'm not interested enough to argue with him.'14:32
hacksenwerkI don't know, I don't use that package anyway, I was just curious if this is an issue or not.14:32
fsmithredprobably not. We're not in the habit of adding a lot of dependencies.14:33
fsmithredI have to go. bbl.14:34
hacksenwerkfsmithred: cya :)14:34
Kitty_do we have any indication on a release date for Daedalus ?16:20
djphKitty: as far as I'm aware, it's still "when it's ready"16:22
guilherm1Hi! I must know: is there something like https://snapshot.debian.org/ for Devuan? I once had a big problem with my Debian installation, and managed to solve it by downgrading some packages. I did it through Debian Snapshot.16:23
djphleast there's nothing new in the mailing list today (or I'm reading the wrong ML :D)16:23
buZzguilherm1: 99% of devuan packages are 1:1 debian packages16:23
buZzso you can totally mess your system up with snapshot.debian as-is16:23
buZzi'd recommend never ever using that :D16:23
buZzbetter to fix underlying issue then to introduce mixed packages, -always-16:24
guilherm1buZz: nice! But it'd be nice if Devuan mantained its own Devuan Snapshot, even if its version contains the 1% of different packages16:24
buZzwell, devuan does have package servers16:25
buZzwhich do have 'all the versions' of packages on it16:25
buZzsnapshot itself doesnt really add anything16:25
guilherm1buZz: I had to do it because of a bug in some packages. Unfortunately, the bug is still unsolved, even in the new Debian stable/Bookworm16:25
buZzbeside 'move pkg to have a datestamp'16:25
buZzguilherm1: what bug?16:25
buZzlink to the issue?16:26
guilherm1buZz: Xorg broke in my setup. It has something to do with my hybrid GPU. I don't know the details, but I'm talking to some friends that have more knowledge than me to find out more details16:27
buZzbumblebee works pretty rocksolid since day1 from all i've seen16:27
buZzi highly recommend NEVER EVER 'take pkg from old distro' just to compensate for not fixing a bug16:28
guilherm1I didn't take from old distro. I was using Debian testing and took it from an older version still in testing. But I know, it isn't the best solution, and I'm still looking for a better way to solve it16:29
guilherm1As soon as as talk with my friends that know the bug better than me, I'll come here to discuss it further, if you wish16:30
buZznah i dont honestly care, i just highly recommend never ever ever doing that16:34
buZzbut i also dont recommend running testing unless you are -testing-16:34
buZzits not a 'my friends said i should do this' distro ;)16:34
djphtesting (daedalus) has been quite nice (I'm glad I pulled the trigger on it for the daily driver ... didn't run into any trouble, except with pulse [no surprises there])16:35
buZzhehe, honestly i'm having pulse issues since moving to chimaera :P16:35
guilherm1I'm just wondering why I'm still having this issue in debian stable :-(16:35
buZzcant find the attention to fix it16:36
guilherm1buZz: about pulse issues, I understand. As we move to testing, we must know that some issues may occur16:36
buZzguilherm1: the issue is that pulseaudio was always demented and we're finally moving away from it16:37
guilherm1buZz: now I'll try to find such devuan mirrors that contain all versions of packages, as you said16:37
buZzwhat about https://pkginfo.devuan.org/ ?16:38
buZzthere is no 'all packages' because most are transparantly grabbed from debian16:38
onefanghttps://pkgmaster.devuan.org/mirror_list.txt to pick package mirrors.16:38
djphbuZz: I mean, it was also b0rken in chimaera.16:38
buZzright16:39
djphwell, "broken".  More just "annoying, but ever-so-slightly less annoying than having to find and kill whatever's locking alsa"16:39
guilherm1buZz: pkginfo.devuan.org shows only the packaged versions that were "stabilized" (they were in stable devuan versions). Devuan Snapshot shows all the compiled versions, even when in Debian Sid/Testing16:40
guilherm1package versions*16:40
guilherm1Debian Snapshot*16:40
guilherm1sorry for the typos16:40
ted-iousBetween releases, the Technical Committee resolved that Debian "bookworm" should support only the merged-usr root filesystem layout, dropping support for the non-merged-usr layout.23:10
ted-iousFor systems installed as buster or bullseye there will be no changes to the filesystem; however, systems using the older layout will be converted during the upgrade.23:11
ted-iousIs daedalus going to be like that too?23:11
fsmithrednot like that on my daedalus23:12
rwpted-ious, I am not authoritative but my understanding is that in the future Devuan will follow Debian on this.  But it hasn't happened yet.23:13
rwpBasically no one likes it but it there is only so much fork work that can be done and so compromises must be made.23:13
ted-iousI guess debian doesn't care about users anymore.23:14
ted-iousHence systemd.23:14
rwpPretty much!23:14
fsmithredalso not like that on the daedalus live-iso I just built.23:15
fsmithredand as I recall, the installer still asks you in expert mode if you want that or not.23:15
fsmithredlast tested 5/27 installer isos23:16
fsmithredbut yeah, it's the future23:16
rwpThere are several fundamental tools like debootstrap and netinst ISOs which are shared but which have different settings between Debian and Devuan.23:16
rwpI am pretty sure that if I debootstrap with Debian and with Devuan that the default results are diverged between them for UsrMerge and a few of the other contentious things.23:17
fsmithredyeah, that sounds right23:17
brocashelmusrmerge and usr-is-merged are permabanned by apt for me23:18
brocashelmdaedalus is otherwise running smoothly23:18
rwpGNU/Linux is a collection of many projects.  My current worst problem is the virt-viewer part of virt-manager libvirt does not capture mouse focus on right and bottom allowing the mouse to exit the VM and lose focus making playing games in a VM impractically tedious.23:20
rwpLast good working version was the Stretch version of libvirt.  Sigh.  I need to dig into what's the actual bug that was introduced there.23:21
debdogback to Stretch, that's quite a stretch23:25
brocashelmi didn't have a good experience with ascii initially23:28
brocashelmbeowulf was much better23:28
rwpOf course Stretch==ASCII but Stretch can be run without systemd so it isn't until the problems of Buster that Beowulf became the absolute needed solution.23:40
ted-iousIs it no longer possible to modify a debian system to run without systemd?23:41
ted-iousIt's been a few versions since I did that.23:42
rwpted-ious, It depends upon what packages you want installed.  If it is one of these https://pkgmaster.devuan.org/bannedpackages.txt then no it is not possible on Debian.  But if you don't need any of those then it is possible.23:44
rwpFor example libvirt on Debian hard requires systemd. Devuan forked the libvirt package and builds it without that dependency.23:46
rwpIf you are not running libvirt then it does not matter to you either way.23:46
ted-iousSo debian intentionally modified libvirt to make it less compatible?23:48
rwpSeveral Debian Developers have been working hard to hard require systemd in every package not just libvirt.23:49
brocashelmsystemd: it will get worse as of trixie23:53
brocashelmcloser to arch levels23:54

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.17.0 by Marius Gedminas - find it at https://mg.pov.lt/irclog2html/!